Summary Getting the Numbers Right Graduates in Electricity Electronics www.krinstitute.org
2,995 words - PDF document - View PDF document
One Line
Malaysia's electrical and electronics (E&E) sector faces challenges with an average annual graduate output of 18,694, underutilization, job mismatch, and the need for the government to improve education, industry-academia collaboration, and salaries.
Slides
Slide Presentation (11 slides)
Key Points
- The government is considering allowing international students who graduate from Malaysian higher education institutions to work in Malaysia, due to a reported increase in foreign direct investment and heightened demand for engineers that Malaysia's current production of E&E graduates is failing to meet
- Analysis of the Graduate Tracer Study (GTS) dataset by the Ministry of Higher Education shows that Malaysia's total E&E graduate output averages 18,694 per year, which is significantly higher than the 5,000 figure mentioned by the Minister
- A significant portion of the available E&E talent pool is being underutilized, with close to 1,000 E&E graduates (degree and above) being overqualified on average, and around 4,000 TVET graduates working in fields unrelated to their studies per year
- High-skilled job creation in the E&E sector has plateaued in recent years, raising questions about the availability and accessibility of these job opportunities for local graduates
- Before implementing a foreign student work pass, the government should prioritize enhancing education quality, strengthening industry-academia partnerships, offering competitive salaries, and fostering an environment that nurtures and empowers local talent
Summaries
26 word summary
Malaysia's E&E graduate output averages 18,694 annually, with TVET graduates contributing. Underutilization and job mismatch are major issues. Government should improve education, industry-academia ties, and salaries.
43 word summary
Malaysia's E&E graduate output averages 18,694 annually, with TVET graduates contributing significantly. Underutilization and job mismatch are major issues. To support local talent, the government should improve education quality, strengthen industry-academia ties, and offer competitive salaries, while prioritizing local graduates over foreign labor.
120 word summary
The Malaysian government's proposal to hire international E&E graduates raises concerns about neglecting local graduates. Analysis shows the total E&E graduates average 18,694 per year, much higher than the 5,000 figure cited. While public university output is around 5,827, TVET graduates average 9,607 annually, highlighting their significant contribution. Underutilization is a major issue, with vertical mismatch affecting 1,000 graduates and horizontal mismatch affecting 4,000 TVET graduates yearly. Job creation growth has plateaued, raising questions about opportunities for locals. To address this, the government should enhance education quality, strengthen industry-academia partnerships, and offer competitive salaries. Initiatives like job placements and mentorship can support local graduates. Any policy should have a sunset clause and prioritize developing local talent over cheap foreign labor.
376 word summary
The Malaysian government's proposal to temporarily hire international students who graduate from local higher education institutions in the Electrical & Electronics (E&E) industry has raised concerns about neglecting the needs of local graduates. Analysis of the Graduate Tracer Study (GTS) data reveals that the total number of E&E graduates in Malaysia averages 18,694 per year, significantly higher than the 5,000 figure mentioned by the Minister. This discrepancy suggests a lack of transparency and data-driven decision-making in the policy proposal.
Further examination of the data shows that the average output of E&E graduates from public universities (IPTA) is around 5,827 per year, consistent with the Minister's statement. However, the output of E&E TVET graduates averages 9,607 per year, almost double the IPTA figure. This highlights the significant contribution of TVET graduates to the overall E&E talent pool, which should not be overlooked.
The underutilization of the current graduate pool is also a major concern. Vertical mismatch affects around 1,000 E&E graduates on average, while horizontal mismatch affects around 4,000 TVET graduates per year. The analysis of job creation in the E&E sector reveals that while total job creation has increased, the growth in high-skilled jobs has plateaued in recent years, raising questions about the availability and accessibility of these opportunities for local graduates.
To address these concerns, the government should prioritize enhancing the quality of education by aligning the curriculum with industry needs, promoting hands-on experience through quality internships, and fostering lifelong learning. Strengthening industry-academia partnerships and offering competitive salaries and benefits to both local and foreign talents are also crucial.
Furthermore, initiatives such as facilitating job placements, mentorship programs, and networking opportunities for local graduates can ensure a smoother transition into the workforce and safeguard their interests amidst increasing competition. Drawing insights from international precedents, such as Australia's Temporary Graduate Visa and Singapore's Work Holiday Pass, can inform Malaysia's strategies.
Ultimately, any policy proposal should be implemented with a clear sunset clause and a timeline for its eventual rollback. The goal should be to supplement the workforce while working on enhancing the capacity of local graduates, rather than substituting them for the purposes of cheap skilled labor. By prioritizing the development and utilization of local talent, Malaysia can foster sustainable economic growth and prosperity for all.
566 word summary
The Malaysian government's proposal to temporarily hire international students who graduate from local higher education institutions in the Electrical & Electronics (E&E) industry has raised concerns about neglecting the needs of local graduates. While international graduates could help bridge the current workforce gap, it is equally important to provide equitable opportunities for local graduates to foster a skilled workforce and ensure long-term growth.
Analysis of the Graduate Tracer Study (GTS) data reveals that the total number of E&E graduates in Malaysia averages 18,694 per year, which is significantly higher than the 5,000 figure mentioned by the Minister. This discrepancy suggests a lack of transparency and data-driven decision-making in the policy proposal.
Further examination of the data shows that the average output of E&E graduates from public universities (IPTA) is around 5,827 per year, which is consistent with the Minister's statement. However, the output of E&E TVET graduates averages 9,607 per year, almost double the IPTA figure. This highlights the significant contribution of TVET graduates to the overall E&E talent pool, which should not be overlooked.
The underutilization of the current graduate pool is also a major concern. Vertical mismatch, where graduates work in jobs that require less qualifications than they possess, affects around 1,000 E&E graduates on average. Horizontal mismatch, where graduates work in fields unrelated to their studies, affects around 4,000 TVET graduates per year.
The analysis of job creation in the E&E sector reveals that while total job creation has increased considerably, the growth in high-skilled jobs has plateaued in recent years. This raises questions about the availability and accessibility of these high-skilled job opportunities for local graduates.
Three key questions emerge from this analysis:
1. Where are the numbers coming from? The discrepancy between the government's claim and the GTS data highlights the need for transparent and data-driven decision-making.
2. What about TVET employability? The significant contribution of TVET graduates to the E&E talent pool suggests the need to examine the efficacy of the TVET curriculum and ensure its alignment with industry needs.
3. What is the intention of this proposal? It is crucial to understand whether the proposal aims to supplement the local skilled workforce or to substitute local talent with foreign workers, as the latter could undermine the long-term sustainability and economic resilience of the workforce.
To address these concerns, the government should prioritize enhancing the quality of education by aligning the curriculum with industry needs, promoting hands-on experience through quality internships, and fostering lifelong learning. Strengthening industry-academia partnerships and offering competitive salaries and benefits to both local and foreign talents are also crucial.
Furthermore, initiatives such as facilitating job placements, mentorship programs, and networking opportunities for local graduates can ensure a smoother transition into the workforce and safeguard their interests amidst increasing competition.
Drawing insights from international precedents, such as Australia's Temporary Graduate Visa and Singapore's Work Holiday Pass, can inform Malaysia's strategies. These policies offer temporary solutions with stringent regulations to prevent exploitation and ensure benefits for both the country and its citizens.
Ultimately, any policy proposal should be implemented with a clear sunset clause and a timeline for its eventual rollback. The goal should be to supplement the workforce while working on enhancing the capacity of local graduates, rather than substituting them for the purposes of cheap skilled labor. By prioritizing the development and utilization of local talent, Malaysia can foster sustainable economic growth and prosperity for all.